| 2023 | Noah A. Horton, IΔ '23 (Georgia Tech) |
| 2022 | Jacob A. Eason, ΞΔ '22 (Texas Tech) |
| 2021 | Jacob Waldrop, XΔ '21 (Clemson) |
| 2020 | Thomas P. Lee, Γ '21 (Ole Miss) |
| 2020 | William H. Cachine, Σ '20 (North Carolina) |
| 2019 | Jason Brovich, ΣΔ '19 (Duke) |
| 2018 | Uday Suresh, ΔΔ '18 (Cal) |
| 2017 | Parth Y. Shingala, P '17 (Rutgers) |
| 2016 | Michael K. Herbert, KΔ '16 (Yale) |
| 2015 | Nicholas N. Strelke, ΣΔ '15 (Duke) |
| 2014 | Cody J. Saben, ΘΔ '14 (Washington) |
| 2013 | Brandon M. Vandergrift, Ξ '13 (Stevens) |
| 2012 | Stephen B. Shepherd, Jr., YΔ '12 (Wake Forest) |
| 2011 | Michael R. Britt, ΔΔ '10, X '11 (Amherst) |
| 2010 | Justin C. Froeber, ΠΔ '10 (NC State) |
| 2009 | Joseph T. Steuer IV, TΔ '09 (Sewanee) |
| 2008 | Mitchell A. Colleran, ΘΔ '08 (Washington) |
| 2007 | Michael L. Wallace, P '07 (Rutgers) |
| 2006 | J. Zach Blend, MΔ '06 (Rollins) |
| 2005 | Travis C. Valentine, ΩΔ '05 (George Mason) |
| 2004 | Jason L. Vargas, MΔ '04 (Rollins) |
| 2003 | Ryan H. Ahlberg, E '03 (Michigan) |
| 2003 | Charles Q. Powell, ΨΔ '03 (Colorado) |
| 2002 | Timothy M. Van de Kamp, I '02 (Wisconsin) |
| 2001 | Edward C. Anderson III, N '01 (Minnesota) |
| 2000 | Peter J.J. Anderson, EΔ '00 (Northwestern) |
| 2000 | Steven A. Starnes, E '00 (Michigan) |
| 1999 | Zebulon M. Winstead, Γ '99 (Ole Miss) |
| 1998 | Matthew S. Gillingham, ΘΔ '98 (Washington) |
| 1997 | Samuel C. Bessey, HΔ '97 (Oregon) |
| 1996 | Andrew C. Sain, IΔ '96 (Georgia Tech) |
| 1995 | Christopher S. Kramp, X '95 (Amherst) |
| 1994 | Matthew E. Cheek, Σ '94 (North Carolina) |
| 1993 | Karl M. Ahlm, EΔ '93 (Northwestern) |
| 1992 | Todd H. Packebush, HΔ '93 (Oregon) |
| 1991 | Richard D. Cochran, M '91 (Middlebury) |
| 1990 | Troy N. Ivey, IΔ '90 (Georgia Tech) |
| 1989 | J. Randy Bremer, ΛΔ '89 (UC Irvine) |
| 1988 | Trevor M. Law, EΔ '88 (Northwestern) |
| 1987 | Vincent A. Gonnella, P '87 (Rutgers) |
| 1986 | Randy S. Stevens, B '86 (South Carolina) |
| 1985 | Michael H. Mountan, EΔ '85 (Northwestern) |
| 1983 | Michael D. Meyer, ΔΔ '83 (Cal) |
| 1982 | Brian E. Shea, Π '82 (Union) |
| 1981 | Ernest P. Votolato, H '81 (Bowdoin) |
| 1980 | Samuel L. Perkins, OΔ '80 (Washington and Lee) |
| 1979 | Robert B. Anderson, Γ '79 (Ole Miss) |
| 1979 | Frank P. LaMonaca, Jr., A '79 (Wesleyan) |
| 1979 | Mark D. Moncino, ΛΔ '79 (UC Irvine) |
| 1979 | Thomas E. Terrell, Jr., Σ '79 (North Carolina) |
| 1978 | Lance A. Henderson, ΔΔ '78 (Cal) |
| 1977 | Hubertus van Der Vaart, Σ '77 (North Carolina) |
| 1976 | Donald T. Hughston, Σ '75 (North Carolina) |
| 1975 | Joseph H. Hodges III, Σ '75 (North Carolina) |
| 1974 | Richard K. Mastain, Jr., H '74 (Bowdoin) |
| 1972 | George E. Butler II, Σ '72 (North Carolina) |
